It’s the final episode of the webtoon, and Kang Chul, Yeon Joo, and Dad are stuck inside the manhwa world until the ending, happy or sad. With the police closing in on them, Kang Chul makes the decision to erase Yeon Joo from his family registry and pulls off their wedding rings. Out in the real world, Crazy Dog reaches this part in the episode and his jaw drops.
Chul asks Yeon Joo to decide what kind of ending they get, promising to follow her lead. So she puts her wedding ring back on and calls his plan nonsense. She reaches for his hand, which is still flickering in and out and threatening to disappear, and slides his ring back on too. She says there won’t be any ending where anyone disappears, and all of them will get out of here together.
He points out that she can’t live in here for the rest of her life, but she says that the three of them can live together, and argues that visiting him in jail for the rest of their lives is better than never seeing him again. Chul doesn’t think such an uneventful ending is possible, but Yeon Joo stubbornly refuses to imagine any sort of ending where Dad and Kang Chul aren’t both by her side. Yeon Joo says that the only options for leaving her are for him to get sick or die of old age, and declares that her decision is made: They will live out the rest of their lives in here and die. The end.
It doesn’t seem like Chul thinks this is possible, but he can’t argue and asks her to draw them an exit and a car for now, so that they can escape. On the drive, Chul says, “You said once that your husband never told you that he loved you… I love you.” It brings Yeon Joo to tears, and she cries silently in the backseat.
Chul drops her off with Dad in a motel before going back to rescue Do Yoon. He tells Assemblyman Han’s henchmen that he wants to see Do Yoon alive before handing anything over, and they turn Do Yoon over to him without a fuss. He’s bloodied and barely conscious, and Chul makes sure that his bodyguards take Do Yoon to the hospital. He remains behind, knowing that this is the deal.
Assemblyman Han is waiting for the tablet, but Chul says he doesn’t have it, and offers up a copy of the CCTV footage of him being tortured in here a year ago. Chul warns him that he has multiple copies, and threatens to turn it over to the police if Assemblyman Han ever attacks one of his people again. Chul adds that he should stop looking for the tablet if he doesn’t want a syringe in his neck, and turns to go. Assemblyman Han stops him with a question: “What if this ends only when you die?” Before Chul can even react, Assemblyman Han pulls out a gun and shoots him in the chest. Gack. It sends Chul tumbling backwards, and he lands on the floor with a thud. Back in the motel room, Yeon Joo notices Dad’s hands suddenly solidifying, and she starts to panic, knowing that this means Chul is in danger.
Assemblyman Han says he heard something strange, about two worlds, and how Kang Chul is the hero of a manhwa and he’s the villain. Assemblyman Han says he thought it was crazy at first, but it explains so much of what he couldn’t understand before. He racked his brains trying to figure out why Chul suddenly couldn’t vanish while he was being tortured, or disappear from prison, and then he pumped Do Yoon full of enough drugs that he finally heard the truth: that this is the final episode, and one of them has to die for it to end.
Assemblyman Han is convinced that if Chul dies, he’ll be able to enter that other world. Chul has stopped listening, and focuses all of his efforts on sliding a chair closer with his foot. Assemblyman Han starts poking Chul in the face with his gun, and decides that he can go find out the truth for himself in that other world.
But Chul is faster, and he kicks the chair so that it slams into Assemblyman Han’s side. Chul rushes him and they wrestle for the gun, choking each other violently. Assemblyman Han screams, “Die!” as they fall to the floor. By the time the henchmen break their way inside, Chul has the gun in hand and shoots them down. He staggers out leaving a trail of blood, and uses up the rest of his bullets on the remaining henchmen, finally resorting to hand-to-hand combat when he’s out of ammunition.
Do Yoon is awake now and yells at his subordinates for just leaving Kang Chul there by himself. They turn back on Do Yoon’s orders, and arrive outside the hideout just in time to see Chul staggering to his car. They focus on stopping the henchmen so that Chul can escape, and though he manages to drive away, he’s in bad shape.
Do Yoon calls Yeon Joo to update her, and she’s relieved to know that he’s alive. But then they both ask each other where Kang Chul is, and she starts to panic. Do-yoon says they’re on the lookout, and asks where she is so that he can send guards to watch over her.
It’s not until hours later that Chul finally calls her, voice trembling and weak. He asks her to pick him up, because of all the things, he ran out of gas. She asks why he didn’t call until now, and he says he fell asleep. He admits that he’s “a little hurt” and can’t manage to see where he is, so he hangs up to go find out. Yeon Joo goes to the tablet and starts drawing herself a car, and asks Do Yoon to look after Dad while she goes searching for Chul.
Chul peels himself out of the car and starts stumbling towards the bus stop, looking like he can barely stand. He finally calls Yeon Joo back and says out the name of the city and bus stop, and almost immediately after hanging up, he coughs up a nasty stream of blood. Yeon Joo asks Do Yoon to call a doctor because they can’t go to the emergency room, and Chul calls her back to ask why she isn’t here. She stifles back tears and says she’s on her way but it’s farther than she thought, and he says softly, “I’m waiting.” Chul says that the final episode doesn’t seem like it’ll go on for fifty years, and he starts to cry as he realizes now that the ending they’d hoped for is impossible. “Who’d read an ending that boring?” he asks. He tries to hold on and says, “Come quickly. I miss you.” She pleads with him to hang on just a little longer because she’s on her way, but the phone falls out of his hand, and his body slumps down.
Yeon Joo finally reaches the bus stop and sees him from across the street, and when she calls out to him, he lifts his head. But then, as if that’s the last thing he was hanging on to do, his eyes close and his body falls limp, and the final chyron starts to render in the corner: “The End.”
Time slows as Yeon Joo sees it happening and she starts to run across the street in tears.
She’s almost there, but a truck zooms by, cutting off her path to Kang Chul. And then… night turns to day, the truck becomes a bus, and once it passes, she’s back in the real world and Kang Chul is gone.
Su Bong rushes to the computer to check the last episode of the webtoon, and then rushes to the bus stop to find Yeon Joo. When he gets there, she’s sitting were Kang Chul was, crying inconsolably. Su Bong just sits next to her quietly, letting her cry.
Crazy Dog reaches the end of the webtoon and has just about the same reaction that I did, like he might throw something at his computer. He’s so upset that he marches out to go pick a bone with Yeon Joo, but Seok-bum says she’s in the emergency room, and clarifies that she’s not working in it—she just got admitted as a patient.
Crazy Dog is stunned to find Yeon Joo wailing so sorrowfully in the emergency room, and he’s suddenly sweet and caring as he asks what happened. She just cries and cries, so he tucks his handkerchief into her hand before he goes. The final straw for Yeon Joo is when her wedding ring disappears right off of her finger, like the tablet and anything else that came from the manhwa world. When Yeon Joo hears that Dad wasn’t in the motel, she yanks out her IV and stumbles out of the hospital. She goes straight to Dad’s workshop to look for the tablet, but Su Bong tells her it’s gone—it was a copy after all, and it came from the manhwa world. He tells her it’s really over now, and she crumples to the floor in another wave of tears.
Yeon Joo spends the ensuing days in a haze of denial and depression, waking up to her collage of Kang Chul drawings and a fresh batch of tears each morning. She goes to the bus stop day after day and waits there to no avail, and she sketches Dad’s face on a new tablet, but it’s only ever Su Bong who walks through the front door.
They finally circulate flyers looking for Dad, and as Yeon Joo sits at the bus stop again, Su Bong narrates, “Yeon Joo noona was the only one who couldn’t accept reality. But the webtoon W completed its seven-year run and ended in September, 2016.” He says that the manhwa’s hero rejected his destiny and dreamt of a happy ending as a real person, but in the end he fell at the hands of the villain and died in front of the woman he loved. Su Bong says that reporters came to Dad’s workshop in search of answers regarding the ending, but Dad never returned.
As people buy the final volume of W in bookstores, Su Bong narrates that most people didn’t think the ending was so strange.
“But…” Su Bong continues, “Nobody knew that the ending wasn’t a sad one.”
In flashback we return to the bus stop as Kang Chul dies, and this time, Yeon Joo vanishes and we stay in the manhwa world, which doesn’t freeze or stop at all—it just keeps going. We go back a few hours to find that Assemblyman Han isn’t dead either, and his henchmen find him stewing angrily in the corner of his warehouse, right where Kang Chul left him. Dad is still tied up in the motel room, and when he hears his bodyguard talking to Do-yoon on the phone, he asks Do Yoon to untie him because it’s faster to help Kang Chul with the tablet than to drive around looking for him.
Do Yoon relents and warns the bodyguard to keep an eye on Dad in case he goes crazy, and Dad begins to draw on the tablet. But ack, the first thing he draws is a syringe in his guard’s neck! Dad waits until the bodyguard passes out and then takes his phone to make a call.
Assemblyman Han pitches a fit at his own assistant, screaming that nothing matters now because he could die at any moment. He’s hysterical, until Dad calls him directly and confirms, “I’m the one who made you.”
Dad asks how Assemblyman Han ended up this way, getting blood on his hands and shooting guns when he’s supposed to be president. Assemblyman Han just wants to know how Dad is here in this world, but Dad asks knowingly, “Did you shoot Kang Chul to find me?” Dad seems amused and says he’s been here for a year, and then the door to Assemblyman Han’s office suddenly locks, and a gun appears in his hand. Dad asks if he’s looking for the reason he exists, and sighs that there’s no way to stop that hunger to know, and it’ll end with some sort of explosion… just like the others before him. “That’s how I ended up this way,” he says.
Dad says that can’t happen though—if a bad guy like him knew all the secrets, what would happen to his world? Dad decides, “That’s too dangerous. You should come with me. I failed at everything else, but I need to take care of you before I go.” Assemblyman Han’s hand starts to flicker and pull the gun up to his own temple, against his will. When he starts to shout, Dad draws a piece of duct tape over his mouth. Time is running out on Dad’s own hand, which is fading quickly, and he draws furiously until he hears the sound of the gunshot.
By the time Assemblyman Han’s assistants bust down the door, he’s shot dead, and the duct tape has been erased. On the desk, Dad has drawn a suicide note along with a USB drive, which must contain all the footage of Kang Chul being tortured.
Dad also sends the cops evidence on Ajusshi’s shooting to prove Kang Chul’s innocence, and then he leaves his own picture and a letter in the bodyguard’s hand before calling Do Yoon. Dad asks where Yeon Joo is, in the hopes of seeing her one last time. Kang Chul sits at the bus stop coughing up blood, and as Dad drives there, he begins to fade almost entirely. His words to Kang Chul are repeated in voiceover—that they couldn’t be together in the end, and that if it were to be a happy ending for one of them, it’d be a sad ending for the other. Dad stops in the middle of the road, arriving just as Yeon Joo gets out of her car across the street from the bus stop. He sees her crying and calling out to Kang Chul, and Dad just smiles at her, at once happy, regretful, and loving. He reaches out a hand, but she’s too far away, and he just says quietly, “I love you, my daughter. Goodbye.” He shuts his eyes and accepts his fate, and then he fades away.
Su Bong narrates that it wasn’t Kang Chul’s death that ended the manhwa, but the villains’ deaths. He explains that their final moments never made it onto the manhwa page because the villain of the story went against his very reason for existing in order to ensure the hero’s happy ending, and he vanished because of it, taking that final story arc with him.
Do Yoon discovers Kang Chul passed out at the bus stop, and Su-bong narrates that nobody knew that Kang Chul was still alive, because the manhwa had simply ended. Chul gets hauled away in an ambulance, with Do Yoon clutching his bloody hand. He’s unresponsive at first, but then… he opens his eyes. Do Yoon yells at him: “I thought you were dead!” And all Chul says in response is, “Oh Yeon Joo…” Do Yoon says that she wasn’t there, and Chul smiles in relief. Su Bong narrates that he knew it then, that his role as the hero of the manhwa was over at last.
Sometime later, So Hee returns to Korea after her business trip and is shocked to hear the news report that Assemblyman Han committed suicide. She visits Kang Chul in prison, and he says that as soon as he healed from the gunshot wound, they stuck him back in here. She assures him that since the murder charges have been dropped, he shouldn’t be in there for too much longer. So Hee apologizes for suspecting him and cutting off contact, but Chul says he was happy when she did, because she proved that she could live a different life.
In his cell, Chul takes out the letter and photo that Dad left behind for him. Do Yoon told him that Dad disappeared without a trace, and passed on the letter. Dad writes that he’d hoped Chul would send him off, but he’s going on his own. Dad says that he’s already dead, and his soul is terminal because he doesn’t know when he’ll go crazy again.
Dad: “You will go out to the real world, and I will end my life here. You will become human, and I will remain a manhwa character. You will break free from the predetermined settings I created, and I will die trapped in the setting I created… Isn’t life funny? Be happy. Make Yeon Joo happy. And if you meet Yeon Joo, tell her that I’m alive, so that she isn’t sad. Tell her that I’m living a better life, inside the manhwa that I drew.”
Su Bong narrates that Kang Chul spent two more years in prison in order to wrap up the manhwa world logically, and that time passed slowly for him. Thankfully, only a week has passed in Yeon Joo’s world. Mom asks her where dad is, and Yeon Joo says without much conviction that he’ll probably show up if they wait a few more days. She goes to Dad’s workshop and lingers in his empty office, and then she returns to the bus stop again. She walks through the pouring rain and sits there, looking utterly broken and lost.
Yeon Joo sits on the curb in the spot where Kang Chul died, getting completely soaked and on the verge of passing out. A car pulls up and stops just a few feet away, and when she opens her eyes, all she sees is a pair of feet walking towards her in slow motion… She begins to fall, and loses consciousness.
When Yeon Joo wakes up, she’s in a bright hospital room, and omo—she’s sleeping on someone else’s arm. She focuses her eyes and sees a man’s hand holding hers, wearing a familiar ring. She turns around to face him, and there’s Kang Chul, spooning her in the morning as if nothing has happened. He opens his eyes and smiles at her, and Yeon Joo still looks like she doesn’t believe it.
He asks how she is, and says that he told Mom to go home and get some rest. He thought Mom would ask more questions, and says he couldn’t very well tell her that he was Yeon Joo’s husband, so he said he was her boyfriend. Mom had asked if maybe they’d broken up at a bus stop, and guesses that this was what Yeon Joo was so broken-hearted about. She asked what Chul did for a living, and he handed her his business card from the manhwa world. You can’t keep doing that!
He tells Yeon Joo that he spent two years in prison, but it’s only been a week here. “I was worried that time would flow the same, and that you’d die from being sad alone. What a relief,” he says with a smile. She finally reaches out a hand to touch his face, and lets herself believe that he’s really here. A tear escapes, and she lets out a trembling sigh of relief.
She asks after Dad, and Chul gets up to get Dad’s picture out of his coat pocket. He doesn’t say anything as he hands it to her, but it seems that Yeon Joo knows what must’ve happened, and she sobs as Chul holds her in his arms.
Sometime later, they sit overlooking the river and Chul points out that he’s now three years older than her. “So you really have to call me oppa now,” he says happily. Yeon Joo asks if it’s really really over, and he assures her that it is. They snuggle and kiss, and Yeon Joo narrates, “Kang Chul’s story in the manhwa was a happy ending, but the real-life Kang Chul and Oh Yeon Joo’s ending is still unknown. But…”
Kang Chul finishes, “The two of them no longer stand at the crossroads of life and death like a manhwa, and although boring and ordinary, we hope that they will get an ending that lasts fifty years. Like other ordinary couples.” As the sun sets, the final chyron appears in the corner: “The End.”
Personal Thought:
As I expect, till the very end of this episode, we all doesn't know right what the reasons of two world can come across together? I told my friend that for the better of the story, the writer should have told the viewers as why things work that way when the episodes reach half-way though, otherwise, they will lose the main point of the story and as you can see, the rating drop to single digit, proving my theory. Some people may not tune in their interest anymore in the ending.
W's ending is an evidence that on going drama may have used all the ideas in earlier episodes, which makes the ending to lose the attractiveness and the main point of the story. Instead, Uncontrollably Fond ends with a solid point of story, much with the depth of emotions too. It’s too bad that the show used up all of the truly amazing mind-blowing twists so early on in the series, because it made the second half feel rather slow and predictable in comparison, only because it started out with such a bang. As I have said, to get a better ending, they should have end the story in Episode 13 already, rather than having a repetitive story line.
I though W is going to be a hit, sadly, they can only gain 10% in rating average. Well, as I expect, this story might not be everyone's cup to taste due to the difficulty of the story, nonsense story line and difficult to understand logic. As far as I see, most people like an easy, realistic and heart touching moment to gain high ratings. Check out for Doctors, Secret Garden (it's a fantasy but they did a good reasoning as to why the magic can work like that), Man From the Star (parallel universe, but they did a good ending), Love in The Moonlight, Moon Embraces the Sun, Descendant of the Sun, Gentleman's Dignity. It's a good thing if the story involves some of the unexpected twist, but it the twist doesn't make sense in every way, nor it could explain the whole thing, I don't think it will become a hit.
I guess the ending where Yeon Joo and Kang Chul to be together is somehow being forced, to fulfill the expectation of the international viewers who demand the happy ending. Right from the start it's a known logic that the love story of two world couldn't come to be real. The timing difference in two world might not work the same. Moreover, when Chul comes to real life, it seems to be an unrealistic ending which I don't really like. But, thinking that this is not a pre-produced drama, thus, I could say that the writer only did what people want.
On the other hand, a pre-produced drama like Uncontrollably Fond sure has a solid story line, since Shin Joon Young died at the end. Pointing out the whole ascpect of the story, rather than fulfilling viewer's expectation. If Kim Woo Bin ended up alive, I would also blame the viewer for making such unrealistic ending. The good thing is that, they didn't do it and left a deep impression for everyone with the ending of Uncontrollably Fond.
Cheers!
